If you clicked through the first part, you already know this title is just a hook and this article is about reviewing common mistakes that ruin Social Media strategies in China. After #1, 2 and 3, respectively “Ignore Social Media”, “Underestimate the Investment” and “Own the Conversation”, here are the 3 following mistakes.
 

 

 

Ink Stain Commercial for CCTV by Niko Tziopanos

Ink Stain Commercial for CCTV by Niko Tziopanos

 

 

How to lead a successful strategy on sns in China ? 6 mistakes to avoid – Part II

 

Mistake # 4 - Define conversions as the only KPI

 

Often, marketers – or sales executive focus only on what drives the direct and final conversions : a lead, an email, keywords campaigns or banner display, neglecting important decision-makers factors such as trust and persuasion.

Social media campaigns have to be handled with the same pragmatism of any other online marketing action but not only  : defining KPIs and clear objectives is the first step to ensure the success of a campaign. Indeed, if I do not know what I want to achieve, how can I tell I succeeded or not?

Using a mix of quantitative metrics - number of times the brand/product is mentionned, number of pageviews, social networks coverage, traffic driven, sales, average order value…together with qualitative ones – accuracy of the targeting is translated by engagement : time spent on site, return rate, positive vs negative word-of-mouth, natural virality…is necessary to measure the effectiveness of such campaigns.

 

Mistake # 5 – See China with your own eyes

 

This mistake is still widely spread among foreign companies in China. Whether for big groups who must respond to a global positioning worlwide and politics that slow them down in their decision process, or smaller companies that still try to replicate foreign models on the Chinese markets, the question is : why so many failures?

Chinese netizens have a very different behavior online than the West : the craving of Generation Y to express itself gives birth to a more participative and interactive web 2.0, leading to the growing importance of social networks and online games. To understand social networks, you have to understand Chinese society.

Rand Han from BloodyAmazing said in this very interesting article The Meta-Reality of China Advertising

 

“Beyond appearance, the true value of a brand is the emotions it elicits when viewed by its market.”

 

What is important to Chinese people? What stirs up their emotions? Keeping in mind thess questions when building strategy is the one ingredient often missing to achieve success.

 

 

Mistake # 6 - Stop your campaign

 

Social Media is about creating a relationship. Many brands build a site, create profiles on numerous social networks, get an audience engaged, make efforts, but just stop after 3 months. Why? Social media marketing is still considered from a traditional 3-months campaign approach and the mistakes mentionned above contribute to ruining campaigns.

Keep on entertaining the relationship, listening to your audience and rewarding your fans/followers. What is the risk ? See results increase, stabilize the budget and get your return on investment…

 

For successful examples, check this L’Oreal case and follow this blog.

 

 

Related articles

How to lead a disastrous Social Media Strategy in China – Part I

Latest Statistics on online SNS usage in China

 Eight Ways to Ruin your Social Media Strategy

Giving Luxury Brands a Chinese Soul

 

China's Social Networks Map by ZeroDegrees

China's Social Networks Map by ZeroDegrees

 

What are the key factors to successfully lead a Social Media strategy in China ? How do you measure success?

 

In a country where 360 millions people surfs on the Internet, it is certainly worth asking these questions. If you are reading this blog, chances are you are at least on the right path for getting some answers. The title is just a hook of course, the real question is :

 

How to lead a successful strategy on sns in China ? – Part I

 

It is difficult to talk companies and brands into Social Media, whether they are conservative or not.

Why? Social Media Marketing (SMM) is a relatively newly used medium for marketers especially in China where they face a general lack of transparency and a tremendous growth of the Internet population. Although we all agree there is something “out there”, it is difficult to find the right model, define KPIs, execute and get a good return on investment.

Whether you already started some social campaigns or just thinking about it, you will encounter a lot of obstacles but the reward might be worth it.

 

Here are 6 big mistakes that keep on ruining social media strategies :

 

Mistake # 1 : Ignore it

The recent statistics on sns population in China published on nov 11th by CNNIC show the following (full article on web2asia.com) :

 

By the end of 2009, China will reach 124 million users of online social networks.

The vast majority of users has accounts on multiple networks – on average 2.78

More than half of SNS users (52.6%) are aged 20-29, which is significantly higher than the average 22.8% of Internet users in that age group.

More than half of Chinese users spend around 1 hour on SNSs, 22.6% spend up to 2 hours per day and 12.8% are logged on for more than 2 hours.

 

So basically, chances are :

1. People are talking about you Instead of letting people talk about you without you, you should go there and talk with them. This will not only help you monitor your branding and message, but this will certainly help you get a better reflection on how people perceive you.

or 2. People are not talking about you. Well they should. This is a unique opportunity to create/position your brand in an effective way. The great thing about having little awareness is that there is plenty of room to say absolutely what you want and brand yourself with more freedom than you are able to once your reputation is built.

 

 

Mistake # 2. Underestimate the investment

Costs

Just because opening a profile on a social network is free does not mean there is a cheap way to lead a good social media strategy. Think about it : the power of social media is that it enables you to reach your targeted customers (current and future) very accurately. Even if this is China, good things come at a price.  It is however a cost effective, long term strategy, requiring at the beginning some investment, but in the long term the costs remain the same more or less whereas your influence keep on growing.  It is also an excellent complement for PR, market research and advertising operations.

 

Resources

Underestimate the power of content : as I wrote in a recent post, quality brings quantity.  The content is the Champagne you bring to a party : original, relevant and entertaining articles, videos, gifts and contests. Anything keeping the people interested in you rather than in your competitor or another distraction.

The Mango case shows that despite their move to social networks Xiaonei, Baidu, Haibao and others, too little effort was made to provide and update content. 

If your company is not big enough to allocate a budget for hiring an in-house social media manager, it is best to have a dedicated staff and contact to monitor campaigns together with the agency in charge of your account.

 

 

Mistake # 3. Own the conversation

 

Most people tend to forget the word “Social” in “Social Media”. Social means living together in organized groups or similar close aggregates, seeking out or enjoying the company of others for convivial activities. The common mistake brands make on social media, be it forums or blogs, is crash in and start a monologue – just like traditional PR sending out press release.

 

We see it very clearly with the Levis Blog example : a blog talking about Levis and nothing else.  The Cartier case study  is also a good example for the don’ts : no benefit, no conversation, no activity, no technical maintainance.

 

As I described in the Social Media Love theory, the ideal relationship between a brand and its customer is positive and emotional. Therefore, your circle of influence is meeting another circle (people) and the interaction between the two are creating a new space : your unique relationship.

 

To be continued …

 

 
Nothing Sadder than an empty glass of Champagne

Nothing Sadder than an empty glass of Champagne

 
What is Social Media Marketing ? I kid you not, I have heard in a meeting with a client “We should do SMS” instead of “SNS”. Good for you. Would you like some M&M’S too?
 
It seems like with all this buzz and name-dropping, people tend to forget to start from the beginning : understand basic principles of Social Media, how to’s and think how it could apply to one’s industry. Some trends don’t fit everybody, just like slim jeans.
 
But even understanding what it is and how it works is not enough.
 
I know what is a plane. I kinda understand how it works with all the forward motion and stuff. But even if I know where I want to go it doesn’t mean I will get there without an excellent pilot (specialized agency), and some fuel - money that’s right, there is no such thing as a good stuff free…
 
Social Media is a powerful tool and like anything powerful – arts, media, a Victoria secret model, H-bomb.., it needs to be in handled with great care.
 
I would like to quote Lafayette – the hysterical black gay character in True Blood, not the French aristocrat and general in the american revolutionary war (what can I say, at least most of you know who I am talking about) :
 
“Don’t blame the Ferrari just because yo’ass can’t drive”
 
Social Media is a Ferrari and needs skilled drivers. Skills like having a deep knowledge of the social media landscape in China and knowing how to use it, using best practices from abroad and being able to adapt them to local behaviors.  
 
Start with content. Recently I heard  ”Content is not very important, I don’t want to focus on that. Just drive traffic to my site and I am happy”
 
 Well, sure. Do you think you’ll have a crowd coming to your house party if there nothing to drink and nothing to eat – in fact, no party ?  I can already see the % of your bounce rate, and it’s no low…And once the people are gone, they are not likely to come back any soon.
 
Why content is the key? Because when you enter social networks, you are not welcomed as a brand. My fellow Buzzman quotes Bob Thacker, senior VP-marketing and advertising at OfficeMax :
« The secret is respecting the consumer.You are interrupting their life. All advertising is unwanted, so if you’re going to crash the party, bring some champagne with you. »
 
 
 What is the champagne you’re bringing ? Content. Entertaining and good stuff  : Champagne yes, Prosecco no. It can be insights, tips, gifts, or just a good laugh but it must contribute to make the readers interested in you enough to come (drive traffic to your site) and talk about you (viral). 
 
Quality only will make Quantity. Chin-chin…
 leviscloud
 
 
It is no news brands and companies are struggling to find alternative and cost-effective ways to sell, survive and possibly stand out in the over-crowded world wide web.
 
Following that Darwinism trend, the model
companies – sell to- customers
seems to become
brands – talk to / with – people
 
(the “with” is very important. At least, some have started picking up on that.)
 
As the second model relies largely on social media (because this is what you want, “socialize”, right?) now brands are beginning to open blogs to reach to the Chinese consumers.
 
I’d love to quote a phrase in article the 7 deadly sins of blogging featuring on excellent blog Copywriter :
“You know that guy at the party who just refuses to shut up? The one who lectures you for 45 minutes about his Warcraft collectible figurines, without ever noticing that you’re desperately wishing you had a cyanide pill so you could quietly end it all?

Don’t be that guy.”

Since brands are stepping in the blogosphere, they might want to apply the same principles :
 
1. Give before asking or taking. Don’t be selfish
2. Provide valuable content.
3. Engage in a dialogue, talk about them and not about you
4. Don’t be boring
 
 
When we take a look at the Levi’s blog in China, it appears none of these principles were applied
 
Hello Levis !

Hello Levis !

I can’t help but think :
- What’s in it for me?
- Content is too much text and looks corporate. I do not want to click through.
- 4 articles talking about Levis : Brand story, Levi strauss and the 501 product story (+ 1 article “hello world” which is actually the default wordpress article whenever you open a blog…(sigh)
 
Seems like we have a Levis blog talking about Levis product…
 
No offense but just because setting up a wordpress blog is easy does not mean you have to do it if you don’t know how to have a strategy and :
 
1. Build content : Give something, aka valuable and entertaining content
2. Build context : the content based on your universe. Levis could bring for example news like hipsters trends or whatever close to the brand
3. Engage in a dialogue by providing a mix of brand stories/news/original content
4. Go online when you are ready…
 
 
Now the good thing is that as it seems it’s just getting started, Levis blog (and many others) can still change their strategy before investing too much time and energy into something that will make them say
 
“Blogging does not work for brands.”
 
 
1 cookie point for blogging, but for the rest, go back to your room and finish your homeworks.

Other articles

 
 
 
12
 
 
Name-dropping, as in “using the name of someone famous or popular to let other people know you are yourself popular and have friends” is a tacky practice, especially when not done properly. By properly I mean knowing the person you are talking about and whose name you are using in an effort to promote yourself or add value to your opinion.
 
Lately I have been meeting with a lot of agencies and professional from the digital industry in China and I have noticed a really hot trend among these fellows : the “social media” name-dropping. Have you noticed too?
 
You get to talk with anyone involved in the internet business and then at some point you hear “Yeah, we do social media too”. I have the feeling most of them are just saying it for the sake of not feeling leftout in the digital game – on both sides, agencies and brands.
 
I’m like “Really? What do you do?”. Most times I get a “We go on Chinese social networks sites, blabla”. But it is no long before the conversation dries up.
 
So, before I typed the term “social media” into Google trends, I had a slight idea about how would look the graph.
 
 

Picture1

 
As we can see, there’s a lot of talk but who can walk the walk?
And who can moon-walk?
 
computer-thrown-out-a-window

 

 
This weekend I went out in a happy socializing mood and inevitably, the question popped up
“What do you do in China?”
 
It’s funny how most people ask you “in China” as if what you do is only relevant as long as you do it here…Anyway I gave my usual and vague answer ” I work in the Web”.
The girl opened her eyes wide and said 
“Can you ask them to bring back Facebook?”
 
Well, sure. As a matter of fact, I am on my way to a little chat with the Politic Bureau see if I can pull some strings and ask them “C’mon, you know, we just want to update our status”.
 
Since Facebook was banned early in July this year, only 14 000 out of the 1 million monthly active users remain according to Facebook Global Monitor. The report does not mention the impact this has on us, survivors :
 
x We can’t randomly update status, tag/comment anymore to remind people on the other side of the world we still exist.
x We can’t upload party pictures to prove our relatives we are having so much fun away from them.
x Now we have to ask people what’s new in their life instead of just checking their profile.
x I can’t know what city should I live in or what would be my ghetto name anymore – this probably increased the productivity of foreign staff working in China.
x Most seriously lots of businesses like restaurants, clubs and hotels were using it to promote their events. How do they do now?
 
The web 2.0 situation is frustrating here : I can’t say how many times a day I come accross a blog or a website, an author and the guy is like “follow me on Twitter” “add me on Facebook” and I feel like a loser uninvited to parties – something I never felt of course in the real life.
Or maybe it is blocked

Or maybe it is blocked

 
But why is Facebook banned in China?
 
x Insight 1 : Politics
 
As a group supporting political activism in Xinjiang appeared on Facebook, the government took sanction against the social network. According to article, Chinese netizens “agreed that Facebook should be punished for that” – nationalism is indeed very strong among Chinese Y generation.
 
What could have been done is ask Facebook to block such groups in China, just like Google was asked to filter results if it wanted to enter the market – but Google generates money as Facebook still struggle to find a long term viable business model so that leads me to :
 
x Insight 2 : Politics + Economic
 
What is the risk for a particpative foreign media/website/business with a popular concept in China ?
They are most probably very welcomed at first, then copied before being banned or blocked. They educate the market before their audience goes to local competitors who do it a lot better because of their better understanding and sometimes the support of the government.
As major foreign players cannot really play without China, they all expose themselves and face the same issue : Yahoo vs Alibaba, Ebay vs Taobao, Google vs Baidu…
This applies to all online models except micro-blogging which is not welcomed no matter what as we’ve seen with the blocking of popular micro blogging site Fanfou (back to theory #1). So basically in this counter-creative environment, foreign models are just used to leverage local ones.
 
What to do? For companies, I’d just say : Who might benefit from the crime? That’s your Achille tendon. Make sure you work with people, Chinese and foreigners, who have experience and a deep understanding of both the country and market. The human factor is the key.
What about you, lonely foreigner facing the Great Firewall ? Get a VPN. Move. Or stop complaining about it.
 
Peace x
Sources